Upon my first viewing of Google’s newest ad, I couldn’t help but question, “Is it just me, or does this seem somewhat off?” This thought ceased to cross my mind after several more viewings.
The advertisement begins with a seemingly mundane scenario: a father discusses his daughter’s admiration for Sydney McLaughlin-Levrone, describing her as potentially the biggest fan of Sydney in the world. She aspires to pen a fan letter to the Olympic champion, seeking her father’s assistance, and that’s when the narrative shifts.
Indeed, the ad showcases Google’s Gemini AI; the father instructs Gemini: “Assist my daughter in composing a letter to Sydney, expressing her admiration and including her ambition to one day surpass Sydney’s world record. And she adds, sorry not sorry.”
At a glance, this seems to align with the broader message of generative AI’s potential as a tool for writing assistance, particularly for those who find the process daunting. And indeed, what’s more daunting than writing to your idol?
Yet, it’s difficult to imagine a less genuine method of conveying admiration than having an AI draft a message about someone’s inspiration. While Gemini only produces a first draft for the father-daughter duo to then customize, the end result would likely be a pile of nearly identical messages for Sydney.
Linda Holmes, novelist and Pop Culture Happy Hour podcast host, sharply criticized this approach, saying, “There are definitely exceptional situations and individuals who require assistance, but as a general narrative of ‘look how convenient, she didn’t have to write anything on her own!’ it’s disheartening. Who desires a fan letter crafted by AI?”
Holmes also highlighted, “Writing a fan letter is an excellent exercise for a young person to practice writing! Directing children towards AI for their writing tasks because they’re not yet skilled writers prevents them from learning effectively.”
I find myself in agreement. While I may never compete in the Olympics, on the rare occasion, even a tech blogger like me appreciates receiving genuine compliments. I’d far prefer a simple, personally written message of appreciation over a detailed, AI-generated letter any day.
This doesn’t escalate to the level of Apple condensing the entirety of human achievement into an iPad, yet it does illustrate some of the challenges in marketing AI as a tool for the everyday person.
Compiled by Techarena.au.
Fanpage: TechArena.au
Watch more about AI – Artificial Intelligence
